LIVE--:--
SPOT
4.8 / 5 on Trustpilot · 54 reviewsPersonal advice · 085 060 3009
Valuation

How do I tell real silver? Five tests you can do at home

At home, real silver is best recognised by its hallmark (925, 835, 800 or STERLING), backed up by four simple tests. None of those tests on its own proves that something is solid silver. Together they give a good first impression; only a measurement gives certainty.

An ice cube melting on a silver bar, with a red horseshoe magnet and a silver spoonAn ice cube melting on a silver bar, with a red horseshoe magnet and a silver spoon
XGOUD1 October 20266 min readBeginner

Test 1: find the hallmark

Use a loupe on the back of a handle, on a clasp or inside a ring. These marks point to solid silver:

  • 999 – fine silver.
  • 925, STERLING or STER – sterling silver, 92.5 per cent.
  • 835, 833, 830 and 800 – common European alloys.
  • A lion or a sword – Dutch hallmarks for silver.

Watch out for 90, 100, EPNS and nickel silver. Those marks mean silver plated or no silver at all.

Gold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glassGold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glass

Test 2: the magnet

Silver is not magnetic. If an object sticks to a strong magnet, it is steel or contains iron, and it is not solid silver.

The reverse proves nothing: copper, brass and nickel silver are not magnetic either. The magnet rules out one kind of fake, no more.

Test 3: the ice cube

Silver conducts heat better than any other metal. Place an ice cube on a solid silver object and it melts noticeably faster than on steel or a plate, because the silver draws in the warmth of the room at great speed.

The limit: copper conducts heat almost as well, so a large silver-plated copper dish can also score well. With small jewellery the difference is too small to see.

Test 4: the white cloth

Rub an inconspicuous spot with a white cotton cloth. Silver oxidises, and a black or grey smear on the cloth points to silver.

It is a clue, not proof: silver-plated work also leaves a black smear, because the outside is silver. A clean, freshly polished object, on the other hand, leaves little behind.

Test 5: the sound

Tap a silver coin or spoon gently against another coin. Solid silver gives a clear, long ringing tone; nickel, tin and many alloys sound duller and shorter.

This test requires a trained ear and a reference piece you know to be genuine. It works poorly for cutlery and hollow objects.

Tests you are better off skipping

Only a measurement gives certainty. At XGOUD we determine the silver fineness by X-ray analysis, without a scratch and while you watch. The valuation is free and without obligation.

  • Acid test – nitric acid is corrosive, gives off toxic fumes and leaves a stain. Leave this to a professional.
  • Bleach – silver turns black in it, but it permanently damages the surface.
  • Scratching or filing – looking under a layer damages the object, and with antiques that can cost value.

SilverAppraisal

Good to know

Questions about How do I tell real silver

How do I tell real silver?

The most reliable sign is the hallmark: 925, STERLING, 835, 800 or a Dutch lion or sword point to solid silver. Look with a loupe on the back of a handle, on a clasp or inside a ring. Watch out for 90, 100, EPNS and nickel silver: those mean silver plated or no silver at all. Magnet, ice cube, white cloth and sound are supporting clues, but none of these tests proves anything on its own. Only a measurement gives certainty; at XGOUD we determine the silver content with X-ray analysis, without a scratch and free of charge.

Is silver magnetic?

No, silver is not magnetic. If an object sticks to a strong magnet, it is steel or contains iron, and it is not solid silver. The reverse proves nothing: copper, brass and nickel silver are not magnetic either, and those are exactly the metals found in plated ware and fakes. The magnet therefore rules out one kind of fake, nothing more. Combine it with the mark, such as 925, 835 or 800, and with the other home tests, and if in doubt have the fineness measured; at XGOUD that costs nothing.

Does the ice cube test really work?

As a clue, with larger objects, yes: silver conducts heat better than any other metal, so an ice cube melts noticeably faster on it than on steel or on a plate. The silver draws the warmth of the room in extremely quickly. It is not proof, because copper conducts heat almost as well, so a large silver-plated copper dish can score well too. With small jewellery the difference is too small to see. Use the test only alongside the mark, therefore, and if in doubt have it measured: that leaves no scratch and costs nothing with us.

Can I test silver with acid at home?

You can, but we advise against it. Nitric acid is corrosive, gives off toxic fumes and leaves a permanent stain; the acid test is therefore a job for a professional with the right equipment. Bleach also damages the surface permanently, and scratching or filing to look beneath a layer can cost an antique its value. An X-ray measurement at a buyer damages nothing and is free. At XGOUD the handheld device comes along to every appointment, in the branch and at your home: it measures the silver content without a scratch or stain, and you see the result yourself.

Is your question not listed? Ask it below, call 085 060 3009 or go to contact.

Your question

Still something unclear?

Ask it here. You will receive a personal reply by email, usually within one working day – no automated message and no phone call you did not ask for.

What others asked
  • An answer from a valuer, not from a template
  • We keep your question so that you need not repeat anything
  • No sales pitch afterwards

Sources

Where you can verify what you have just read.

  • LBMAThe London gold and silver price our daily rate is built on
  • WaarborgHollandThe Dutch assay office that verifies fineness and strikes hallmarks

Rather just have it looked at?

A valuation is free and without obligation, at a location near you.