LIVE--:--
SPOT
4.8 / 5 on Trustpilot · 54 reviewsPersonal advice · 085 060 3009
Jewellery

Pearl necklace, amethyst, garnet: what are pearls and semi-precious stones worth?

The honest answer first: with most pearl necklaces and pieces with amethyst, garnet or citrine, the resale value lies in the gold or silver, not in the pearls or stones. There are exceptions, and they are easy to recognise.

A pearl necklace with a gold clasp, a gold ring and coloured semi-precious stones on red velvetA pearl necklace with a gold clasp, a gold ring and coloured semi-precious stones on red velvet
XGOUD1 October 20265 min readBeginner

Natural, cultured and imitation pearls

A natural pearl grows in a mollusc without human help and is very rare. Almost all pearls in jewellery made since the early twentieth century are cultured pearls: a farmer inserts a nucleus or a piece of tissue into the shell, and the animal then coats it with nacre. Imitation pearls are glass or plastic with a pearly coating.

A simple first check: rub a pearl gently along the edge of your teeth. Real pearls, natural or cultured, feel slightly gritty; imitations feel smooth. You only know for certain after testing.

Gold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glassGold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glass

What decides the value of a pearl necklace?

Most pearl necklaces consist of cultured freshwater or Akoya pearls. These are farmed in large quantities and have little second-hand trade value. Large South Sea and Tahitian pearls of good quality are higher. For every pearl, the following count:

  • Lustre: how sharply a pearl reflects light.
  • Size, in millimetres.
  • Shape: the rounder, the rarer.
  • Surface: pits and spots lower the value.
  • Matching: how well the pearls of a necklace go together.

Look at the clasp. A pearl necklace often has a clasp of 14 or 18 carat gold, sometimes with a small diamond. That clasp has ordinary material value, even if the pearls bring in little.

Amethyst, garnet, aquamarine: semi-precious stones

'Semi-precious stone' is an old trade term for coloured stones such as amethyst, garnet, citrine, topaz, peridot, aquamarine and tanzanite. Gemmologists hardly use the term any more, but the distinction it makes largely holds: most of these stones are common and have a modest trade value per stone.

Exceptions are large stones of top quality, especially aquamarine and tanzanite, and stones in a signed piece from a well-known house. There, the stone or the design can bring in more than the metal.

How we assess a piece with pearls or stones

Worth knowing beforehand: we buy the precious metal, not the pearls or the semi-precious stones. We pay nothing for those, genuine or not. That is not a bargaining position but our trade: we buy precious metal, we are not a stone dealer, and bidding on something we have no market for would give you a false picture of what it is worth.

  • The precious metal first. We determine the fineness, weigh the piece and fairly deduct the weight of pearls and stones. We pay for the metal at the day’s rate.
  • Then we look for anything of note. Our gemmologists assess whether there is a stone or pearl that genuinely means something as a stone. If there is, we say so – and we advise you *not* to sell it along with the gold. Have the stone removed from its setting, or find a specialist buyer or auction for it.
  • Then the whole. If a piece is worth more as jewellery than its parts, a signed design for instance, we say so as well. Melting down a piece that is worth more as jewellery is a waste, and we will not be party to it.

Jewellery

Good to know

Questions about pearl necklace, amethyst, garnet: what are pearls and semi-precious stones worth

How much is a pearl necklace worth?

With most pearl necklaces, made of cultured freshwater or Akoya pearls, the second-hand trade value of the pearls is low. A gold clasp does have material value, and the metal is what we buy – for the pearls themselves we pay nothing. If they are large South Sea or Tahitian pearls of good quality, we say so and point you to a specialist buyer or an auction, where they will fetch more than with us.

How can I tell whether my pearls are real?

Rub a pearl gently along the edge of your teeth: real pearls, natural or cultured, feel slightly gritty, whereas imitations of glass or plastic feel smooth. That is a first test, not certainty. Whether a real pearl is natural or cultured can only be established by testing; almost all pearls in jewellery made since the early twentieth century are cultured. Real does not mean valuable either: cultured freshwater and Akoya pearls have little second-hand trade value. So look at the clasp too, which is often 14 or 18 carat gold and simply has material value. We buy the precious metal, not the pearls.

Is a piece with amethyst or garnet worth a lot?

Usually the value then lies in the gold or silver, and that is the part we buy. Amethyst and garnet are common and have a modest trade value per stone; for semi-precious stones we pay nothing. Large top-quality stones and signed jewellery are the exception – you will hear that from us, with the advice not to sell them along with the gold.

Is your question not listed? Ask it below, call 085 060 3009 or go to contact.

Your question

Still something unclear?

Ask it here. You will receive a personal reply by email, usually within one working day – no automated message and no phone call you did not ask for.

What others asked
  • An answer from a valuer, not from a template
  • We keep your question so that you need not repeat anything
  • No sales pitch afterwards

Sources

Where you can verify what you have just read.

  • LBMAThe London gold and silver price our daily rate is built on
  • WaarborgHollandThe Dutch assay office that verifies fineness and strikes hallmarks

Rather just have it looked at?

A valuation is free and without obligation, at a location near you.