LIVE--:--
SPOT
4.8 / 5 on Trustpilot · 54 reviewsPersonal advice · 085 060 3009
Diamond

What is a 0.5 or 1 carat diamond worth when you sell it?

There is no fixed price for 'a 1 carat diamond'. Two stones of exactly the same weight can be far apart when sold. What makes the difference, and why the shop price of back then is no guide to today’s offer.

A diamond on a precision scale reading one carat, with two smaller stones and tweezers on feltA diamond on a precision scale reading one carat, with two smaller stones and tweezers on felt
XGOUD1 October 20266 min readAdvanced

Why is diamond priced per carat?

With diamond, a carat is a weight: exactly 0.2 grams. The trade works with a price per carat, which you multiply by the weight of the stone. Half a carat is 0.50 carat, a whole one 1.00.

That price per carat is not the same for every weight. Larger stones are rarer, so a carat in one large stone costs more than a carat in two small ones. A 1 carat stone is therefore worth well over twice as much as a comparable half-carat stone.

Gold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glassGold rings, a link chain and a coin on a felt appraisal tray, with a magnifying glass

The jumps at round weights

The price per carat does not rise gradually but jumps at round weights: half a carat, one, one and a half, two. A 0.99 carat stone and a 1.00 carat stone cannot be told apart by eye, yet the second sits in a higher price bracket.

That is why a buyer weighs to a hundredth of a carat. With a set stone, the weight is estimated from the diameter and depth; if the weight is on a report, that figure applies.

What decides the buying value of a 0.5 or 1 carat stone?

Besides weight, five characteristics count:

  • Colour, from D (colourless) to Z (clearly tinted). Between two letters you see little difference by eye, but the price does.
  • Clarity, from FL (no inclusions under magnification) to I3. Inclusions visible to the naked eye push the price down sharply.
  • Cut: for round brilliants the cut grade from Excellent to Poor, and the shape. Round, princess, emerald and cushion each have their own price level.
  • Fluorescence: strong blue fluorescence can mean a discount on colourless stones.
  • The report: a report from GIA, HRD or IGI removes uncertainty. Without one, gemmologists assess the stone themselves.

Why the offer is lower than what you paid in the shop

The shop price of a diamond ring includes the jeweller’s margin, the work on the setting, advertising and VAT. When you sell, you receive the trade value of the loose stone: what a trader can pay for it at that moment. That gap is large with every piece of jewellery and has nothing to do with your stone.

We work with the trade prices per carat of an international diamond trading platform, for natural stones with the characteristics our gemmologists measure. Our diamond calculator shows you in advance the order of magnitude of your stone; the final offer follows after measurement.

Lab-grown is outside this. Everything above is about natural diamond. A grown diamond has hardly any resale value; we only buy it from 3 ct, and we name the price at the appointment.

DiamondPrices

Good to know

Questions about what is a 0.5 or 1 carat diamond worth when you sell it

What is a 1 carat diamond worth when you sell it?

There is no fixed price: two 1 carat stones can be worth many times each other when sold. With diamonds a carat is a weight of 0.2 grams, and besides that weight, colour (from D to Z), clarity (from FL to I3), cut, fluorescence and the report all count. A stone of 0.99 carat also sits in a lower price bracket than one of 1.00 carat, even though you cannot see the difference. A gemmologist therefore has to measure the stone. The diamond calculator gives an order of magnitude for natural diamond in advance; the final offer follows the measurement.

Is half a carat worth half as much as a whole carat?

No, less than half. The price per carat rises with weight because larger stones are rarer: a carat in one large stone costs more than a carat in two small ones. A 1 carat stone is therefore worth well over twice as much as a comparable half-carat stone. That price per carat does not rise gradually but jumps at round weights: half a carat, one carat, one and a half and two. That is why a buyer weighs to a hundredth of a carat. With a set stone the weight is estimated from the diameter and depth, unless a report states the weight.

Why do I get less than I paid in the shop?

Because the shop price contains far more than the stone: the jeweller’s margin, the work on the setting, advertising and VAT. When you sell, you receive the trade value of the loose stone, meaning what a dealer can pay for it at that moment. That gap applies to every diamond, including a very good one, and has nothing to do with the quality of your stone. We work with the trade prices per carat of an international trading platform for natural diamond, using the properties our gemmologists measure. With a lab-grown stone the gap is even larger; we only buy those from 3 ct.

Is your question not listed? Ask it below, call 085 060 3009 or go to contact.

Your question

Still something unclear?

Ask it here. You will receive a personal reply by email, usually within one working day – no automated message and no phone call you did not ask for.

What others asked
  • An answer from a valuer, not from a template
  • We keep your question so that you need not repeat anything
  • No sales pitch afterwards

Sources

Where you can verify what you have just read.

  • LBMAThe London gold and silver price our daily rate is built on
  • WaarborgHollandThe Dutch assay office that verifies fineness and strikes hallmarks

Rather just have it looked at?

A valuation is free and without obligation, at a location near you.